DonkeyHR vs greytHR
greytHR is the incumbent in Indian SMB payroll and the product we most often replace. It is also genuinely good at the thing it is known for. Here is where each of us actually wins.
The short version
Where greytHR is genuinely better
A much longer compliance track record
greytHR has processed Indian payroll through many more Budget cycles, statutory amendments and edge cases than we have. That history is the strongest thing on their side of the table and it is not something a newer product can claim its way past. If you are a risk-averse buyer whose primary fear is a statutory error, weigh it seriously.
Attendance and shift depth, including biometric
greytHR handles rostered shifts, overtime and biometric device integration. We do not. Our attendance is mark-and-approve with regularisation, and it feeds payroll as loss of pay — that is the whole of it. If biometric attendance or shift rostering is your number one requirement this year, greytHR is the better answer and you should not let us talk you out of it.
Breadth of surrounding modules
greytHR carries expense claims and other modules we have deliberately deferred to a second version. Some of those sit behind their higher tiers, but they exist, and ours do not.
Familiarity inside the finance function
Your CA or payroll consultant has probably used greytHR before and has not used us. That matters more in practice than feature tables suggest, because the person filing your returns has opinions about the tool they file from.
Where we are better
Exit and full-and-final settlement, included
Notice-period recovery, leave encashment, and gratuity computed under the Payment of Gratuity Act — 15/26 of last-drawn Basic + DA per completed year, the five-year qualifying period waived on death, capped at ₹20,00,000 — plus a departmental clearance checklist that blocks payment until sign-off, and a printable statement. greytHR gates this behind a higher tier.
An interface built this decade
This is the most consistent thing reviewers say about greytHR, and it is the reason most of our conversations start. It is not a vanity point: a cluttered interface is what makes payroll software need a two-week implementation and a designated internal expert.
Published pricing, no demo gate
Our per-employee prices are on the pricing page in full. greytHR's are tiered and gated, which means an evaluation starts with a sales call rather than a number. If you are comparing on cost, you can compare with us today.
Restricted-holiday quotas that work properly
Employees pick their own optional holidays from the published list up to an org-set quota, and only the ones they picked count as non-working for them. greytHR has this; most cheaper tools fake it by treating every optional holiday as a company holiday for everyone.
Correcting a finalised payroll run
The thing buyers actually ask about in demos. A mistake found after a run is closed books against the next period rather than rewriting a locked one, which keeps the audit trail intact and the earlier payslips true.
Side by side
| DonkeyHR | greytHR | |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory payroll (PF, ESI, PT, TDS) | Included on every plan | Core to the product |
| Compliance due-date calendar | Included, with the rule cited for every date | Included |
| Exit and full-and-final settlement | Included | Higher tier |
| Attendance | Mark-and-approve with regularisation, feeding loss of pay | Deeper — shifts, overtime, biometric integration |
| Expense claims | Not yet | Available |
| Pricing visibility | Published per-employee rates | Tiered, quoted on enquiry |
| Free tier | Free forever, up to 50 employees — attendance, leave, ESS | Withdrawn from public signup |
| Trial | 14 days, no card, live the same day under 50 employees | Available on enquiry |
| Track record | New — first year | Long-established |
What we do not have yet
This is the same list our own sales team is told not to oversell. If any of it is your top requirement this year, we are probably not the right answer and would rather you knew now.
- Native biometric or geofenced attendance, and shift rostering with overtime — a deliberate second-version decision, not an oversight.
- Expense claims.
- Performance reviews and OKRs — an explicit non-goal for version one.
- A native mobile app. Employee self-service is a responsive web app that works in any mobile browser.
- Self-serve billing management. Billing is handled manually in our first year.
- DocuSign-grade e-signature. Our letters use typed-name plus one-time-code acknowledgment with a full audit trail and a public verification page — legally reasonable for HR letters under the IT Act, but if you have strict e-signature requirements, raise it with us before you buy rather than after.
- Leave balances reconstructed as at a date before July 2026. The movement ledger starts there; earlier dates report as unknown rather than showing you a zero we cannot stand behind.
Which one you should pick
Choose greytHR if…
You need biometric attendance or shift rostering this year; you want the longest possible statutory track record behind your payroll; or you need expense claims and performance reviews from the same vendor.
Choose DonkeyHR if…
You are replacing a system your team avoids using; exit settlement matters to you and you do not want to pay for a tier to get it; or you want to see prices, start a trial and run a real payroll before speaking to anyone.
Common questions
- Is DonkeyHR a good greytHR alternative?
- For small and mid-sized Indian companies whose main complaint is the interface, implementation time, or paying for a higher tier to get exit settlement — yes. If your main requirement is biometric attendance or shift rostering, greytHR remains the better product and we would tell you so on a call.
- How does DonkeyHR pricing compare to greytHR?
- We publish per-employee monthly rates in full on our pricing page with a ₹1,499 monthly minimum. greytHR quotes on enquiry across tiers, so a direct rupee comparison depends on the quote you are given — but the structural difference is that features like exit settlement are included with us rather than tier-gated.
- Can I migrate mid-financial-year from greytHR?
- Yes. Mid-year migration is supported, which matters because a mid-year switch has to carry your year-to-date figures across or your TDS projection and Form 16 will be wrong. This is the part of a migration worth testing carefully with any vendor, including us.
- Does DonkeyHR handle the ESI wage-ceiling edge case?
- Yes — ESI coverage is fixed for the whole contribution period, so someone who crosses ₹21,000 in June keeps contributing on their actual higher wages until September. Honestly, we had this wrong ourselves until July 2026; it is fixed and pinned by tests now, and you can check it yourself on our public ESI calculator.
Check the claim rather than taking it
The part of this page you should not take on trust is the statutory competence, and it is also the easiest part to verify. Our public calculators run on the same engine as our payroll — put a real mid-period ESI case or a four-year-eleven-month gratuity through them and see whether the working holds up. Then do the same with whatever you use today.
Try the statutory calculatorsOur pricing is on the pricing page, in full, without a form in front of it. Other comparisons: see all.